I finally decided to do just a little bag of candy - Dove Hearts and Hershey Gold Nuggets and created a little topper that said, "For a teachers with a special heart, you are a treasure". Cheesy I know, but hopefully it made them smile and even if it didn't the chocolate was good! I'm sharing the image I created below. I used it as a treat bag topper and printed my kids names on the back fold over portion. This is just the graphic that could be used as a card or treat topper or any other number of ways.
To all the amazing teachers out there - Thank you for all you do! I am sincere when I say I don't think I could do it.